From offside calls to red cards, the Premier League has seen countless controversial refereeing decisions. Explore the most debated moments in football history.

The Most Controversial Refereeing Decisions in the Premier League

Refereeing in the Premier League is no easy job. With the fast pace, intense competition, and millions of fans watching worldwide, referees are under constant pressure to make the right decisions. However, throughout the history of the league, there have been countless moments of controversy, where wrong calls, debatable penalties, or missed fouls have led to major talking points.

Even with the introduction of VAR (Video Assistant Referee), controversial moments continue to spark debates among fans, players, and pundits. In this article, we take a deep dive into some of the most controversial refereeing decisions in Premier League history.

1. Chelsea vs. Manchester United (2012) – The “Phantom” Offside Goal

One of the most debated games in Premier League history took place in October 2012 when Chelsea hosted Manchester United.

• Chelsea, down to nine men, conceded a winning goal by Javier Hernández.
• However, replays showed that Hernández was in an offside position when he tapped the ball into the net.
• Despite protests from Chelsea players, the goal was allowed to stand, and Manchester United won 3-2.

This match was also infamous for the controversial red cards given to Branislav Ivanović and Fernando Torres, both of which were highly debated decisions.

2. Tottenham vs. Manchester United (2005) – The Mendes Ghost Goal

One of the most shocking referee errors came in a 0-0 draw between Tottenham and Manchester United in 2005.

• Pedro Mendes attempted a long-range shot from near the halfway line.
• United goalkeeper Roy Carroll misjudged the ball, allowing it to cross the line before he quickly scooped it out.
• Shockingly, the referee and linesmen didn’t award the goal, even though TV replays clearly showed the ball had crossed the line by a significant margin.

This incident is often cited as one of the reasons why goal-line technology was later introduced in football.

3. Liverpool vs. Sunderland (2009) – The Beach Ball Incident

One of the strangest goals in Premier League history came in 2009 when Liverpool faced Sunderland at the Stadium of Light.

• A beach ball thrown onto the pitch by a Liverpool fan ended up deflecting Darren Bent’s shot into the net past goalkeeper Pepe Reina.
• Despite the fact that the goal should have been disallowed for interference, referee Mike Jones awarded the goal, and Sunderland won 1-0.

FIFA rules clearly state that a foreign object interfering with play should result in a drop ball, but the decision stood, leaving Liverpool fans furious.

4. Arsenal vs. Newcastle (2011) – The Abou Diaby Red Card

This infamous match saw one of the biggest comebacks in Premier League history, but it was also full of controversy.

• Arsenal were leading 4-0 against Newcastle when Abou Diaby was sent off for pushing Joey Barton after a rough challenge.
• The decision completely changed the game, and Newcastle staged a remarkable comeback to draw 4-4.
• Many felt that while Diaby’s reaction was aggressive, Barton’s initial challenge should have been punished as well.

This match remains one of the most dramatic and debated in Premier League history.

5. Manchester City vs. Tottenham (2019) – The VAR Handball Drama

VAR was introduced to eliminate controversial decisions, but in this match, it did the opposite.

• In the 2018-19 Champions League quarter-final, Manchester City’s last-minute goal against Tottenham was ruled out for handball.
• A similar incident occurred in the 2019-20 Premier League season, where Gabriel Jesus’ stoppage-time winner was ruled out due to an accidental handball by Aymeric Laporte.
• The new handball rule had been changed, leading to confusion and outrage among fans and players.

Many believed the decision was too harsh, as Laporte’s handball was unintentional. This moment fueled the debate on whether VAR was truly helping or harming football.

6. Chelsea vs. Arsenal (2014) – The Diego Costa Controversy

Diego Costa was known for being aggressive and pushing the limits of the game, but in a 2014 match against Arsenal, he escaped punishment for multiple offenses.

• Costa shoved, hit, and scratched Arsenal’s Laurent Koscielny but did not receive a red card.
• Instead, Arsenal’s Gabriel Paulista was sent off for retaliating, despite barely making contact.

The decision by referee Mike Dean was widely criticized, and many believed Costa should have been the one sent off instead.

7. Liverpool vs. Everton (2020) – The Van Dijk Injury and VAR Mistake

One of the biggest VAR controversies came during the Merseyside Derby in 2020.

• Virgil van Dijk suffered a season-ending injury after a dangerous challenge from Everton goalkeeper Jordan Pickford.
• However, since Van Dijk was offside, VAR did not review Pickford’s challenge, meaning he escaped punishment.
• Later in the game, Liverpool’s winning goal was ruled out for an extremely tight offside decision on Sadio Mané.

This match reignited debates about VAR’s inconsistency and its failure to protect players from dangerous challenges.

8. Manchester United vs. Sheffield United (2021) – Maguire’s Foul Ignored

Manchester United’s 1-2 loss to Sheffield United in 2021 came with a highly controversial decision.

• United’s captain Harry Maguire appeared to push and foul a Sheffield defender before United’s goal, but VAR did not intervene.
• However, Sheffield’s goal earlier in the match was disallowed for a similar challenge, leading to claims of inconsistency in refereeing decisions.

This match was another example of VAR failing to maintain consistency in crucial decisions.

Conclusion – The Never-Ending Debate on Refereeing Decisions

Refereeing mistakes are part of football, but they often lead to frustration, debate, and even rule changes. Whether it’s offside calls, VAR decisions, or missed fouls, controversial moments will always be part of the Premier League’s story.

Even with goal-line technology and VAR, refereeing decisions continue to create headlines and heated debates. Do you think VAR has improved the game, or has it made things worse? Let us know your thoughts and keep supporting WYN8 – the greatest sport in the world! ⚽🔥

See another football news